Logo
  • About the Economic Futures Hub
  • Unit 1: Economics of the Market
  • Unit 2: UK Economic Activity
  • Unit 3: Global Economic Activity
  • Data for Applied Economists
The Economic Problem

The Economic Problem

📈
The basic economic problem refers to the scarcity of resources in relation to the unlimited wants and needs of individuals and society.
  • So what is scarcity?
  • There are many ways we can define scarcity:
  • Can you think of other real-world examples of scarcity?
  • What methods can we use to reduce the impact of Scarcity?
  • 10 examples of how we can reduce the impact of scarcity:
  • Knowledge checkpoint: Answer these actual Higher Economics exam questions:
  • Concept of Choice
  • What is the opportunity cost?
  • Effect of opportunity cost/scarcity on different groups - individuals, firms and governments
  • Knowledge checkpoint: Answer these actual Higher Economics exam questions:
  • Scarcity vs Shortages
  • What is a shortage?
  • Summary Table of Scarcity vs Shortage
  • Unlimited wants vs. demand exceeds supply
  • Permanent vs. temporary
  • Wants never fully satisfied vs. can be solved
  • Universal whereas Limited to a certain market
  • Economics goods and free goods
  • What is an economic good?
  • What is a free good?
  • Summary Table of Economic Goods vs Free Goods
  • Use of scarce resources vs. abundantly supplied
  • Production has an opportunity cost vs. production does not deplete scarce resources
  • Carries a price vs. does not command a price
  • Examples
  • Can you think of any more examples of Economic Goods?
  • Can you think of any more examples of Free Goods?
  • Knowledge checkpoint: Answer these actual Higher Economics exam questions:
  • Scarcity in Different Economic Systems
  • Planned Economies (Command Economies)
  • Market Economies
  • Mixed Economies:
  • Knowledge checkpoint: Answer these actual Higher Economics exam questions:

So what is scarcity?

There are many ways we can define scarcity:

1️⃣
Scarcity is the problem of unlimited wants faced with finite resources

Human wants are unlimited, but resources are limited. Scarcity is one of the key concepts of economics. The demand for a good or service often exceeds its availability because society's resources are finite.

‣
Resources are known as the factors of production:

The problem of scarcity arises because there are never enough resources to satisfy all our needs and wants.

2️⃣
Scarcity is a universal problem that affects all economies

Regardless of a country’s wealth or stage of development, scarcity is a constant reality because human desires always exceed the resources available. Different economies try to tackle scarcity through various methods, but the fundamental issue remains everywhere.

3️⃣
Scarcity as a Relative Concept

Scarcity isn't just about the physical quantity of resources but also about how much people want them compared to what is available.

Relative scarcity describes a situation where a resource is limited in relation to demand.

🍕Pizza example: If you and three friends all want the last pizza in the shop, that pizza is scarce because demand (four people) outstrips supply (one pizza). If only one person wants it, then it wouldn’t be considered scarce.

Scarcity is therefore a relative concept, depending on the balance between how much is available and how much people want it.

4️⃣
Scarcity arises due to human greed/competing wants

Competing wants: People have a wide range of desires, and these desires can conflict. For example, two people might want both:

📱 a new phone

🌞 a vacation

However, you might not have enough money for both. This competition for resources creates scarcity.

  • Greed: If everyone hoards resources or wants more than they need, it can make them seem scarcer than they truly are.
5️⃣
Scarcity is permanent

No matter how much we produce, people will almost always want more. Our wants and needs grow faster than our ability to supply them. This means we constantly have to make choices about how best to use and distribute scarce resources.

‣

Can you think of other real-world examples of scarcity?

🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿
Does Scotland have a water scarcity problem?

“Unless we take steps to adapt, more than half of Scotland’s population will be at risk of water scarcity by 2050 during very dry periods”

Tackling the impacts of climate change and water scarcity.

Proposals for water and wastewater services.

www.gov.scot

Tackling the impacts of climate change and water scarcity.

What methods can we use to reduce the impact of Scarcity?

10 examples of how we can reduce the impact of scarcity:

🛠️
Discovery of new resources for example finding new reserves of oil

Think of it like finding extra pockets of a valuable good—when you discover new sources of a resource, you temporarily alleviate scarcity by increasing its availability.

🏋🏽
Specialisation in order to improve efficient use of scarce resources

Specialisation involves focusing on a specific task or product. Just as an athlete perfects one sport, producers concentrate on a narrower range of goods or services to become more efficient, reducing the impact of scarce resources.

⚡
Resource substitution can help reduce the pressure on finite resources

Replacing fossil-fuel cars with electric vehicles is a good example. By switching to alternatives, such as renewables or newer technologies, we alleviate dependence on scarce resources like oil.

👀
Alternative resources can be sought

Using solar and wind energy instead of coal and oil is another way to reduce our reliance on resources that may run out, making it easier to cope with scarcity in the long run.

🌍
Geographical mobility of resources can be improved

Encouraging people to move from areas of high unemployment to places with more job opportunities can address labour shortages and reduce scarcity in certain regions.

💼
Occupational mobility can be improved

Training programs that give people flexible skills make them more adaptable and reduce scarcity of skilled workers in specific fields.

🚂
New production techniques to increase productivity

From robotics on the assembly line to new management styles, finding ways to produce more output with the same inputs helps us stretch limited resources further.

👷🏽‍♀️
Encouraging immigration to increase the supply of labour

Immigration increases the supply of labour, which can be a valuable resource for a growing economy. This can help reduce the scarcity of workers in certain industries.

🥴
Reducing level of wants

For example:

  • Sustainability Education: Knowing how our choices impact the environment is crucial. By learning about sustainability, we might choose to buy less stuff, reducing the pressure on scarce resources.
  • Price mechanism: Imagine a limited number of concert tickets being sold for a super high price! The price mechanism can act as a "rationing" system. When something is expensive, fewer people might buy it, reducing scarcity for those who really want it (but are willing to pay the price).
📉
Ensure the economy is efficient

An efficient economy uses resources wisely (productive efficiency), allocates resources to the right places (allocative efficiency), and keeps everyone working (full employment). This helps us get the most out of what we have and deal with scarcity effectively.

Knowledge checkpoint: Answer these actual Higher Economics exam questions:

‣
Describe what is meant by the basic economic problem of scarcity (Worth 3 marks)
‣
Explain methods of reducing the impact of scarcity (Worth 3 marks)

Concept of Choice

💭
Because resources are limited, we must make choices. In economics, scarcity means our resources (money, time, raw materials) can never satisfy everyone’s wants or needs. Therefore, every decision we make involves a choice.
😋
Example: Suppose you have £5 and want to buy both Tesco Finest Scottish shortbread (£3) and a tartan scarf (£4). You cannot afford both, so you must decide which one you value more. This decision involves an opportunity cost.

All choices made by individuals, firms, or governments have a cost associated with them, known as the opportunity cost.

What is the opportunity cost?

❓
Opportunity cost is the value of the next best alternative that you sacrifice when making a choice. In simpler terms, it’s what you give up whenever you decide on one option over another.
⚠️
All societies face this issue. Whether it’s a consumer deciding how to spend money or a government allocating tax revenue, there is always a trade-off. Opportunity cost helps us think about these trade-offs more clearly.

Effect of opportunity cost/scarcity on different groups - individuals, firms and governments

Group
Effect of opportunity cost
Effect of opportunity cost on decision-making examples
Individuals
Every day, you and I face choices with opportunity costs.
Personal Choices: Deciding whether to spend money on a concert ticket or save it for a new phone.   Time Management: Choosing to spend time studying versus hanging out with friends.    Career Decisions: Choosing between taking a job immediately or going to college.
Firms
Firms cannot produce everything they want due to limited resources and revenue. They must prioritise how to allocate resources to maximise profits.
Resource Allocation: Deciding whether to invest in new technology or expand the workforce.   Product Development: Choosing to develop a new product line versus improving an existing one.   Market Entry: Deciding whether to enter a new market or consolidate in the current market.
Governments
Governments have limited tax revenue so cannot provide all the services they want to.   Governments have to make choices about how to spend revenue to maximise social welfare.
Budget Allocation: Choosing to fund healthcare over education.   Policy Decisions: Deciding to implement environmental regulations versus economic growth initiatives.   Infrastructure Projects: Choosing to build new highways versus investing in public transportation.
🛠️
Importance of Scarcity, Choice, and Opportunity Cost: Scarcity helps us understand decision-making in the face of limited resources. The valuation of scarce goods and services, like gold and diamonds, highlights their importance in economic choices and resource allocation.

Knowledge checkpoint: Answer these actual Higher Economics exam questions:

‣
Explain the ways scarcity affects the choices made by Firms (2 marks)
‣
Explain the ways scarcity affects the choices made by Governments (2 marks)

Scarcity vs Shortages

⚠️
It is easy to use the terms “Scarcity” and “Shortage” interchangeably.

While both relate to limited availability, scarcity is a permanent condition arising from the imbalance between our limitless wants and finite resources. In contrast, a shortage is a temporary market situation where demand exceeds supply at a particular price.

What is a shortage?

A shortage happens when there is not enough of a particular good or service to meet the demand at a specific time. This can be due to things like production issues, sudden high demand, or supply chain problems. Unlike scarcity, which is permanent, a shortage is temporary and can be fixed over time as the market adjusts. Take the Covid-19 pandemic as an example:

🧻
COVID-19 pandemic and shortages: Some people, driven by greed or a desire to be overly prepared, hoarded large quantities of toilet paper far beyond their needs. This created a temporary shortage, even though there wasn't a true lack of toilet paper production capacity!
Coronavirus panic: Why are people stockpiling toilet paper?

Loo roll has become the top "panic buy" item in several countries after coronavirus fears.

www.bbc.co.uk

Coronavirus panic: Why are people stockpiling toilet paper?
💡
NOTE: Scarcity refers to the naturally limited availability of something that can’t be immediately replaced when they are used up. Natural resources, for example, can’t be replaced on demand if we’ve used them all up.

A shortage is a market phenomenon. It happens when more people want to buy a product than there is available at the current price. This is a temporary situation that can be fixed by making more of the product or changing the price.

💪🏽
You may be asked to compare scarcity and shortage in your Higher Economics exam. Here we will provide a summary table of these comparisons and explain them in more detail!

Summary Table of Scarcity vs Shortage

Scarcity
Shortage
Unlimited wants
Demand exceeds supply
Permanent- can never be resolved
Temporary
Wants never fully satisfied due to human nature
Solved by a rise in price/an increase in supply
Universal
Limited to a certain market

Unlimited wants vs. demand exceeds supply

💡
Scarcity means we have limited resources, like land, water, and labour, but people have unlimited wants. This natural limit creates a constant state of scarcity because there are always more things people want than what is available.

Shortages, on the other hand, happen in the market when demand for something exceeds the supply at the current price.

💃 For example, with Taylor Swift concert tickets, a shortage occurred as the number of fans wanting to buy tickets exceeded the number of tickets available. This is a temporary situation caused by the market, not by nature, and can be fixed by adjusting prices or increasing supply.

Why are Taylor Swift tickets so hard to get? The economics are complicated

The maths are simple. Most Taylor Swift fans wanting tickets to her Australian shows will miss out.

theconversation.com

Why are Taylor Swift tickets so hard to get? The economics are complicated

Permanent vs. temporary

💡
Scarcity is a permanent condition because resources are always limited compared to human wants. Shortages are temporary and can be resolved through changes in price or supply.

Wants never fully satisfied vs. can be solved

💡
Scarcity implies that human wants can never be fully satisfied because of limited resources. Shortages do not necessarily relate to the nature of human wants but to current market supply-demand imbalances.

For Taylor Swift’s concerts, ticket providers can:

1) increase supply of tickets or 2) increase the price.

Universal whereas Limited to a certain market

💡
Scarcity is universal. It affects all countries, all markets, and all people—no economy can produce enough to meet *every* possible want.

In contrast, shortages only affect specific markets at certain times. They can come and go depending on how quickly supply can adjust to demand.

Knowledge checkpoint: Answer these actual Higher Economics exam questions:

‣
Compare scarcity with a shortage (Worth 2 marks)

Economics goods and free goods

What is an economic good?

💡
Economic goods are items or services that have a benefit to society but require the use of scarce resources to produce. Because these resources are limited and can be used in other ways, economic goods have an opportunity cost, meaning that producing one thing means giving up the opportunity to produce something else. People are willing to pay for economic goods, which means they carry a price and can be traded in the market.

What is a free good?

💡
Free goods are items that are abundant in supply and do not require the use of scarce resources to produce. They are available in such large quantities that consuming them does not reduce their availability to others. Free goods are plentiful, therefore, they do not have an opportunity cost, do not carry a price, and cannot be traded in the market.

Summary Table of Economic Goods vs Free Goods

Economic good
Free good
Requires scarce resources to produce it
Is abundant in supply
Production has an opportunity cost
Production does not deplete scarce resources
Carries a price
Does not command a price
For example a car
For example air

Use of scarce resources vs. abundantly supplied

🛠
Economic goods require limited resources that have alternative uses. For example, producing a car requires steel, rubber, and labour, all of which are limited and could be used for other purposes.

Free goods are available in large quantities and don't require scarce resources for their use. Air, for example, is abundant in supply and we can breathe it without it running out.

Production has an opportunity cost vs. production does not deplete scarce resources

🌬️
When we produce an economic good, we have to give up something else. For example, if we use steel to make a car, we can't use that same steel to build a bridge. This trade-off is called an opportunity cost.

Free goods do not require sacrificing other resources. When you breathe air, you do not prevent others from doing the same, and it doesn't use up any other limited resources.

Carries a price vs. does not command a price

💳
Economic goods have a price because they are limited and desirable. The price is a way to ration these goods. For instance, cars are sold for money because not everyone can have one for free.

Free goods don't have a price because they are not limited. Since there is plenty of air for everyone, nobody needs to pay for it.

Examples

🚗
A car is an economic good because it uses limited resources, has an opportunity cost, and costs money to buy.

Air is a free good because it is abundant in supply, does not have an opportunity cost, and is free for everyone to use.

‣

Can you think of any more examples of Economic Goods?

‣

Can you think of any more examples of Free Goods?

💡
NOTE: Public goods such as street lighting and healthcare are free at the point of use but that doesn’t make them “free goods”. This is because public goods are not free to society because we pay for them indirectly through taxes.
💡
Food for thought: is water actually a “free good”?

It seems like it is everywhere, right? Well, a free good is something that's available without any limits or costs. At first, water might seem like that, but in some places, there's not enough of it. For example, in dry areas where there's not much rain, water becomes scarce. This means it's not always easy to get, and we might need to put a lot of effort and resources into making sure everyone has enough to drink. So, even though water seems abundant in supply, it is not always free or unlimited. This is sometimes known as a “common good”.

Knowledge checkpoint: Answer these actual Higher Economics exam questions:

‣
Distinguish, using examples, between economic goods and free goods. (Worth 3 Marks)

Scarcity in Different Economic Systems

🚨
Scarcity, the limited availability of resources compared to our wants and needs, exists in all economic systems. Here's how different systems approach it:

Planned Economies (Command Economies)

🏛️
In a planned economy, decisions about the allocation of scarce resources are taken centrally - resources are allocated by means of government plans.
🏛️
Scarcity Management:
  • Resources are allocated for the benefit of the state rather than individuals.
  • Rationing: The government might use rationing systems to distribute scarce goods, like food or clothing, equally among the population.
  • Production Focus: The government might prioritise specific industries deemed crucial for the nation, even if consumer demand lies elsewhere.

Advantages: This system can prevent extreme poverty and reduce inequality, as the government can ensure that resources are distributed more evenly.

Disadvantages: They are not allocatively efficient. Planned economies struggle with allocating resources efficiently because they rely on predictions instead of real-time consumer choices. 

👩‍🍳 Imagine a bakery only baking what planners think people want, not what they actually buy. This can lead to shortages of popular items and gluts of unwanted ones, wasting resources and leaving people unsatisfied.

🏛️
What are Gluts?

A glut means there is too much of something. In other words, the supply of something exceeds demand, i.e., there is an oversupply.

🏛️
How do gluts occur in a planned economy?

Planned economies predict demand for goods, but without the constant feedback of consumer choices, mistakes happen. They might overestimate how much people want something, leading factories to pump out a glut (a big excess) that nobody buys.

🏛️
What is an example of gluts in a planned economy?

China: In the late 1950s, China's Great Leap Forward, a centrally planned economic push, aimed to rapidly increase agricultural production. However, inaccurate estimates and unrealistic targets resulted in a glut of some crops, while others remained in short supply

Read more about this here:

Great Leap Forward: What It Was, Goals, and Impact

The Great Leap Forward was an economic campaign in the late 1950s to evolve China from an agrarian economy to an industrial one that ended in disaster.

www.investopedia.com

Great Leap Forward: What It Was, Goals, and Impact

Market Economies

📈
In a market economy, economic decisions are made by individuals and businesses based on supply and demand, with little government intervention.
📈
Scarcity Management:
  • Price Mechanism: Prices are determined by the interaction of supply and demand. If a resource is scarce, its price will rise, signalling to producers to produce more and consumers to consume less.
  • Competition: Businesses compete to provide goods and services, leading to innovation and efficiency. This helps to allocate resources to their most valued uses. Resources (labour, materials) are allocated based on market forces - businesses invest in producing goods and services with higher demand and profitability.

Advantages: Market economies are often very efficient at producing a wide variety of goods and services and encouraging innovation.

Disadvantages: Without government intervention, there can be significant inequality, and some essential services (like healthcare) might be underprovided.

📈
Vertical Farming Takes Root (Literally!)

Hong Kong, a densely populated city with limited land, is a prime example of how a market economy adapts to scarcity. One innovative solution is the rise of vertical farms. These are indoor farms that stack growing layers vertically, maximising crop yield in a minimal footprint.

How it relates to scarcity:

  • Limited Land, High Demand: Hong Kong has limited land for traditional agriculture, but the demand for fresh, local produce remains high.
  • Market Forces Drive Innovation: The high cost of land incentivises businesses to find creative solutions like vertical farming. This allows them to meet consumer demand for fresh produce while overcoming the challenge of limited space.

Read more about it here! 👇

This Hong Kong farm is using fish and blue lights to grow basil the size of your face | CNN Business

In an industrial warehouse in Hong Kong, Farm66 is pioneering smart ways to grow fruit and vegetables. It says its tech could help to produce food in new environments — from city centers to outer space.

edition.cnn.com

This Hong Kong farm is using fish and blue lights to grow basil the size of your face | CNN Business

Mixed Economies:

🌐
A mixed economy combines elements of both planned and market economies. Both the government and private sector play roles in economic decision-making.
🌐

Scarcity management:

  • Government and Market Balance: The government intervenes in certain areas, especially to provide public goods and services, such as education and healthcare, and to regulate the market to ensure fairness.
  • Private Enterprise: Individuals and businesses are free to produce and sell goods and services, with market forces determining prices and production levels.

Advantages: This system allows for a balance between economic efficiency and social welfare. The market can respond to consumer demands while the government can step in to correct market failures and provide for public needs.

Disadvantages: The challenge is to find the right balance between government intervention and market freedom, which can sometimes lead to inefficiencies or overregulation.

Knowledge checkpoint: Answer these actual Higher Economics exam questions:

‣
Describe the allocation of resources in a planned economy. (Worth 2 marks)
Logo

Who are the Fraser of Allander Institute?

Created by Economic Futures. We are hosted by the FAI. Contact us at economicfutures@strath.ac.uk for feedback or collaboration.

LinkedInXYouTube