- 📊 Introduction to Markets 📊
- Combining Supply and Demand
- ⚖️ Market Disequilibrium: When Things Get Out of Balance ⚖️
- What is Market Disequilibrium?
- What are the effects of changes in demand and supply on equilibrium level?
- Test Your Knowledge with Scenarios
- 🛠️ What mechanism can solve market disequilibrium? 🛠️
- What is the Price Mechanism?
- What are the main functions of the price mechanism?
- How can the price mechanism solve the market disequilibrium?
- Price as a basis for market clearing
- Excess demand
- Excess supply
- Are there any real life examples of market clearing in Scotland?
- Joint demand and competitive demand
- Joint demand
- Competitive demand
- Summary comparison of Joint demand and Competitive demand
- Knowledge checkpoint: Describe, using an example, what is meant by joint demand
- Knowledge checkpoint: Compare Joint demand and competitive demand
- Joint supply and competitive supply
- Joint supply
- Competitive supply
- Summary comparison
- Knowledge checkpoint: Describe, using an example, what is meant by joint supply.
- The impact of taxes and subsidies on consumers and producers
- The impact of taxes on consumers and producers
- The impact of subsidies on consumers and producers
- Let’s take a recent real life example of a subsidy:
- Let’s use a supply and demand diagram to understand the impact of the CJRS subsidy on consumers and producers (businesses):
📊 Introduction to Markets 📊
Combining Supply and Demand
✅ Equilibrium is when there is no tendency for the market price to change. At this point, the quantity demanded equals the quantity supplied.
👉 But what happens if something changes?
⚖️ Market Disequilibrium: When Things Get Out of Balance ⚖️
What is Market Disequilibrium?
👉 Changes in the conditions of demand and supply can shift the equilibrium price and quantity, causing a temporary market disequilibrium until a new equilibrium is established.
What are the effects of changes in demand and supply on equilibrium level?
Go through the figures to see these effects:
Diagram | Change | Equilibrium price | Equilibrium quantity |
1 | Demand increases | Higher | Higher |
2 | Demand decreases | Lower | Lower |
3 | Supply increases | Lower | Higher |
4 | Supply decreases | Higher | Lower |
Test Your Knowledge with Scenarios
These questions will test your ability to understand and analyse shifts in supply curves. Pay close attention to the details provided in the case study.
Practice drawing BOTH demand and supply curves for scenarios like the ones below to prepare effectively 👇
Situation: Due to a significant shortage of sunflower oil and extremely dry weather conditions in Spain, the production and availability of Spanish olive oil are impacted.
Question: "Draw a diagram to show the effect on the market for Spanish olive oil due to the reduced availability of sunflower oil and abnormally dry weather in Spain.”
Situation: The government has introduced a 'fat tax' on unhealthy food and imposed stricter restrictions on advertising unhealthy food, impacting its market dynamics.
Question: "Draw a diagram to show the effect on the market for unhealthy food as a result of the introduction of a ‘fat tax’ and increased restrictions on advertising unhealthy food.”
Situation: Both the EU and US governments have introduced subsidies to support the aircraft industry. However, there has been a worldwide suspension of most air travel due to the COVID-19 pandemic.
Question: "Draw a diagram to illustrate the effects of these subsidies from the EU and US governments, combined with the global suspension of air travel, on the market for aircraft.”
🛠️ What mechanism can solve market disequilibrium? 🛠️
What is the Price Mechanism?
- Consumers decide how much they are willing to pay for a product.
- Businesses decide how much they want to charge for that product.
These decisions interact in the market, and the price is determined by the forces of supply (how much of a product is available) and demand (how much of a product people want). Essentially, it’s the buyers and sellers together who determine the price of a product.
👉 In short, the price mechanism is the system where supply and demand decide the prices of goods and services.
What are the main functions of the price mechanism?
- Prices act as signals to show where resources are needed.
- Prices rise and fall based on scarcity (shortage) and surplus (extra supply).
- 📱Example: If the price of smartphones goes up because everyone wants one, this signals manufacturers to make more smartphones.
- 🍊Example: If there are too many oranges and not enough buyers, the price of oranges will drop to encourage people to buy more.
- Prices provide incentives for consumers and producers.
- Consumers’ choices send information to producers about what they need and want.
- 🚙 Example: If more people start buying electric cars, it tells car manufacturers to make more electric cars.
- Prices help ration scarce resources when demand is higher than supply.
- When there is a shortage, prices go up, so only those who are willing and able to pay can buy the product.
- 🎮 Example: If there is a limited supply of a new video game console, the price may increase, and only those who are willing to pay more will get one.
What does “Price as a basis for exchange” mean?
→ Price assigns a specific value to a product or service, making it easier to understand how much something is worth.
- 🍭 A candy bar priced at £1 means that the candy bar is worth £1.
→ Prices enable buyers and sellers to agree on the terms of exchange.
- If you have £1 and want a candy bar, you can exchange your £1 for the candy bar because both you and the seller agree on the price.
For example:
The Scottish Government supports energy price caps to protect consumers from excessive energy prices. By capping the prices that energy companies can charge, the government helps ensure that energy remains affordable, particularly for low-income households. ⚡️
How can the price mechanism solve the market disequilibrium?
Price as a basis for market clearing
👉 Excess demand and excess supply are states of disequilibrium in a market
- let’s figure out how the price mechanism works to solve these two states of market disequilibrium by looking at the market for a particular good:
Excess demand
Excess supply
Are there any real life examples of market clearing in Scotland?
→ Prices of accommodation for the 2024 Fringe Festival has increased by up to 1500% due to the excess demand!
Joint demand and competitive demand
Joint demand
🎮 Similarly, if you buy a new video game console, you will also need games to play on it to make the most of your purchase.
These are examples of complementary goods, which are products used together. Complementary goods automatically have joint demand. For instance:
- You use a smartphone and a phone case together.
- You use a video game console and video games together.
- You use milk and tea to make a great morning drink.
- You use lipliner with lipstick to create the perfect lip combo.
👉 This means that the demand for two or more goods is interdependent or complementary.
Let’s illustrate this example in a demand and supply diagram:
Competitive demand
Think about the name “competitive demand.” The word "competitive" suggests rivalry, tension, and competition.
What goods/services are normally in competition with each other? Can you think of any?
Here are some examples 😁
- Coca-Cola vs. Pepsi
- Coffee vs. Tea
- O2 vs. Vodafone
- Tesco vs. Asda
🔔 Hopefully this is ringing a bell - what do we call these kind of goods? Substitute goods!
👉 Remember substitute goods are products that can be used in place of each other.
- 🛍️ Tesco vs. Asda. Since these services are substitutes, a consumer in theory gets equal satisfaction whether they buy from Tesco or Asda. Therefore, competitive demand means that consumers can derive equal satisfaction from substitute products.
Let’s illustrate this in a demand and supply diagram:
Summary comparison of Joint demand and Competitive demand
Joint demand | Competitive demand |
Consumers require a combination of 2 or more products for maximum consumer satisfaction | Consumers can derive equal satisfaction from substitute products |
These are complementary goods | these are substitute goods |
for example, smartphones and smartphone cases | for example, 02 and Vodafone |
Knowledge checkpoint: Describe, using an example, what is meant by joint demand
Knowledge checkpoint: Compare Joint demand and competitive demand
Joint supply and competitive supply
Let's briefly introduce two more important concepts in economics: joint supply and competitive supply.
Joint supply
💭 Did you know that during the processing of cotton to make fabrics, cottonseed is a major by-product? Cottonseed can be used to produce cottonseed oil, which is used in cooking and food products.
So, when we talk about joint supply:
- An increase in the production of cotton for fabrics results in more cottonseed being produced.
- This demonstrates joint supply, where the production of one good (cotton) leads to the production of a by-product (cottonseed).
We can illustrate our cotton and cottonseed example in a demand and supply diagram:
Competitive supply
Let's use Aldi's strategic decision to introduce a new line of vegan products amidst a growing trend: 8.6 million people in the UK are following a meat-free diet:
- 👉 This is an example of competitive supply, where Aldi must decide which product line will attract more customers and generate more profits.
- 👉 If Aldi dedicates more resources to vegan products, they might have to reduce the resources allocated to other popular items - there is an opportunity cost here!
- 🌱 Opportunity Cost: There is trade-off involved in resource allocation.
- This choice requires Aldi to evaluate which product line will yield the highest customer satisfaction and profitability.
We can illustrate our supply of vegan and meat products in a demand and supply diagram:
Summary comparison
Joint Supply | Competitive Supply |
The production of one good automatically results in the production of another | Resources are allocated between different products that compete for those resources |
These are by-products that are produced together | These products compete for limited resources like land, shelf space, or budget |
For example, Cotton and cottonseed | For example, vegan products and meat products in a grocery store |
Knowledge checkpoint: Describe, using an example, what is meant by joint supply.
The impact of taxes and subsidies on consumers and producers
The impact of taxes on consumers and producers
→ Taxes alter the prices consumers pay and the costs producers incur, affecting consumption patterns and production decisions across the economy.
If we take the example of a tax on the use of gasoline (petrol):
When taxation reduces producer surplus and consumer surplus, it means:
- For Consumers: Prices increase, reducing their purchasing power and satisfaction from consuming goods.
- For Producers: Profits decrease, lowering their motivation to produce more goods and invest in production.
Overall, this reduces economic efficiency and welfare in the market.
Summary:
Consumer surplus: A + C + E
Producer surplus: D + F + B
Government Tax revenue: C + D
Consumer surplus: A
Producer Surplus: B
Tax burden to the consumer: C
Tax burden to the producer: D
Deadweight loss: E + F
The impact of subsidies on consumers and producers
🔍 Think of a subsidy as grants/aids from the government to businesses to keep their operations running.
Let’s take a recent real life example of a subsidy:
Businesses suffered significant losses due to reduced activity. Many couldn't afford to keep paying their workers and needed support to keep going. → On 20th March 2020 the Coronavirus Job Retention Scheme (CJRS) was announced to provide grants to employers during the Covid-19 pandemic in the UK.
🎯 Objective: Prevent mass unemployment by helping businesses retain employees during periods of reduced economic activity.
💼 How It Worked: The government paid 80% of employees' wages (up to a certain limit) for hours not worked, allowing employers to keep staff on the payroll even if they couldn't operate normally.
📈 Impact: This subsidy helped millions of workers across the UK, including Scotland, maintain their jobs and incomes during the pandemic.
→Read more about the CJRS’s impact here:
Let’s use a supply and demand diagram to understand the impact of the CJRS subsidy on consumers and producers (businesses):
- Producers: Increased revenue and profit due to lower production costs and government support.
- Consumers: Increased consumer surplus due to lower prices.
- Market: Lower equilibrium price, increased equilibrium quantity, and higher overall welfare.
This analysis shows how the CJRS subsidy during the COVID-19 pandemic helped stabilised both supply and demand, supporting the overall economy by maintaining employment and consumer spending.
For instance, The Fraser of Allander Institute found that during crises, subsidies aimed at households can lower living costs, especially benefiting lower-income families who spend more of their income on energy.
Subsidising businesses helps maintain economic production but doesn't directly reduce living expenses. The best approach depends on policy goals: for fair distribution, demand-side subsidies targeted at consumers are effective, whereas supply-side subsidies support economic output. Often, a combination of both policies is used to achieve balanced outcomes.